Friday, April 13
The Mark Of Cain
The Mark of Cain
(Thursday. Channel 4. 9PM)

There’s no substitute for moral courage – that was the sermon preached by Tony Marchant’s The Mark Of Cain. The truth may hurt, but it’s a message you should never dilute. Stand up for your convictions.

Admirable sentiments, but I can't help feeling that they were somewhat undermined by Channel 4’s decision to pull the drama last week.

The idea that a television drama (even one as powerful and captivating as The Mark Of Cain) might worsen diplomatic relationships with Iran and jeopardise the release of the captive sailors seems to be a little fantasist on the part of Channel 4.

But then who would’ve ever predicted that a few loose comments on Celebrity Big Brother would trigger an international diplomatic row?

But that’s the power of television it seems – it captures our empathy and our intrigue, and makes things so much more real.

And what better example than The Mark Of Cain – a spellbinding feature film dealing with the abuse of Iraqi detainees by British servicepersons. This was a brave and brutal drama which set out to shatter any romantic and naive notions about camaraderie. Loyalty, we found out, is a euphemism.

But this was sophisticated stuff – it was anything but a straightforward moral onslaught against the British troops. Marchant prefers to work with real characters, and not caricatures – and he ensured that none of his characters strayed beyond redemption.

Even L/Cpl Quealy – written off by The Guardian’s Charlie Brooker as a ‘stock TV nasty’ – raised an interesting defence. ‘Forget what the public thinks: they’re all fucking hypocrites. They don’t care about the treatment of Iraqis – you don’t seem them demonstrating outside Belmarsh do you?’. True, quite true.

This was a spectacular drama which left us searching deep inside our consciences before passing verdict on its characters – were they monsters or martyrs? Posing dark Dostoyevskian questions it served as a chilling reminder of the reality of war and the power of drama.
posted by Robert Henry Jackman @ 02:58  
1 Comments:
  • At 16 April 2007 at 05:35, Blogger Christopher Whalen said…

    Hi Robert,

    Thanks for your comments about my review. I wanted to like this film more than I did. By "one-sided" I mean that none of the characters are sympathetic. I hardly think the British Army is so full of monsters (although my prejudices could well conceive that if I allowed them to rule). The fact that right-leaning politicians and commentators (e.g. Michael Gove on Newsnight Review) objected to this film suggests that it is one-sided. It's hardly a recruitment film, unlike many of the US movies about war.

     
Post a Comment
<< Home
 
I'm tired of trying to get my foot in the door. It's time to follow the example of DCI Gene Hurt. It's time to kick the door down.
See my complete profile


Name: Robert Henry Jackman
Home: Norwich, Norfolk, United Kingdom

Opinions on...
Archives
Links